The Virginia State Beekeepers Association had another great Fall meeting a few weeks ago, focusing on Honey Bee nutrition. The keynote speaker, Dave Mendes (President of the American Beekeepers Federation), focused on protein feeding. To his operation (of many thousands of hives that he trucks to California (Almonds) and the northern states (Blueberries & Cranberries)), feeding protein at the right time makes all the difference. His mantra is ‘good food + clean comb + good genetics = success’. I have long been a proponent of clean comb and good genetics, but have not focused much on nutrition. It has always been my belief that bees with good genetics will find the right food, unless the beekeeper takes it all (which I don’t.) But, I am starting to rethink this idea.
For a couple of years now, a successful beekeeper in Buckingham county that I collaborate with, has been talking up nutrition, specifically in the Fall (which was the theme of a couple of talks at the VSBA meeting.) I have always been reluctant to experiment with this, ONLY because of the SHB. I had found out early on that pollen patties in my hives in August meant SHB problems. But, Dave had an answer for that – you put your feed mix (he called it protein feed, as opposed to pollen feeding) into a wax paper bag with a single slit in it – giving the bees an easy area to defend. He also stressed that you only wanted to give them what they could eat in a couple of days. These two items have me thinking that next Fall I will give protein feeding another shot, in a hive or two. We’ll see how it works.
It only makes sense that giving the bees a source of quality protein at this time (early August for me) would be beneficial. In early August, they are raising the bees that will eventually raise the bees that go into Winter, or what I call the ‘fat bees.’ This is a critical time for all beehives, so a little extra quality feed can help. Dave Mendes recommended the publication ‘Fat Bees Skinny Bees’ by Doug Somerville (sp?), as this seemed to be the basis of his methods.
Another really interesting talk focused on Nosema ceranae. The researcher had found that it appears that this newest Nosema has been around longer then we had thought. In addition, it is starting to look like it is displacing Nosema apis. It’s hard to say whether this is a good thing or not. Regardless, we are seeing an increased presence of this virus, so they are watching it closely.
There was another great talk on feeding, by a fellow along the VA/NC line who focuses on selling bees and queens. He mirrored much of what Dave said, but was even more adamant about the early Fall feeding. He had found that feeding at this time was much better for the bees then any type of feeding in the Spring (syrup or protein) or even feeding during the Winter months. The bottom line was that he found that his bees came out of Winter much healthier with a focused, late Fall feeding. He also noted that the presence of Drones, Drone larva and Drone eggs was a big determinate for feeding protein at other times of the year. Bees with weak protein stores or sources would eat the Drone larva first, then the Drone eggs, for protein. A lack of both of these, in a Spring/Summer hive, was a sign that the quality of the pollen coming in was poor.
There were many other good tidbits of knowledge, but those are the ones that hit home the most for me at this stage. I want to start looking at Fall nutrition. We’ll see where it takes me!
Reader Comments
glad to hear fall protien feeding is being discussed. As you know i am a firm believer in the power of the pollen pattie (or whatever you want to call it)… i have spent hundreds on these and glad others see it worthwhile.
You have SHB so its a bit different, but based on what i have seen in the previous years in the differences between my hives and others who dont feed i will continue even when SHB hits me…
I dont spend the time on making my own… tried it and its too time consuming, i woudl buy a concrete mixer if i planed to do it again…
For the time being i will use Mann Lakes Bee Pro patties or Dadant’s Mega Bee, both of which i have used successfully.
A full size hive can consume a lb patty placed in the brood nest (not on top) but between the boxes, paper and all within 7 days, most likely within 4-5 if not less…
I doubt you will have SHB problems in the center of the brood nest… i just place the patty bwteen my knees, pop the top box and slide the patty in and go to the next one…
I also use patty consumption as a tell tale sign of a failing hive… when a hive that should be consuming a lb in 7 days is not and still has some left i know they dont have enough larva to feed, since nurse bees are the only ones who consume pattys… they only eat the pattys when feeding larva… it was a great tool for early problem finding without doing inspections all the time this year… saved a ton of time…
Your post has me wondering if I have ever tried to feed a strong hive – I may have only tried to feed the weaker ones in the hopes of helping them get going. Of course, weak = poor defense against SHB. Thinking about your words, I am definitely going to try some patties next fall on a couple of test hives (that are strong).